CASY Stock 12 Month Analyst Forecast
Consensus Rating
Loading...
Consensus Price Target
Highest Price Target
$860.00
0.22% Upside
Mean Price Target
$642.15
-25.17% Downside
Lowest Price Target
$450.00
-47.56% Downside
Recent Analyst Ratings
Upgrades, Downgrades, New Coverage
Last Updated On Apr 27, 2026
Actual EPS vs Estimated EPS
CASY Earnings Per Share (EPS) History
According to financial reports, CASY (NYSE: CASY) reported an actual EPS of $3.49 for the quarter ending on Mar 09, 2026, compared to an estimated $3, resulting in a 16.33% surprise. In the prior quarter (Dec 09, 2025), CASY recorded an actual EPS of $5.53 with a 6.55% surprise. See CASY's full earnings history.
Earnings History
EPS Surprise Factor Analysis
CASY has experienced notable EPS surprises, with the latest quarter ending Mar 09, 2026 showing a 16.33% beat. Previously, the quarter ending Dec 09, 2025 recorded a 6.55% beat. An EPS surprise factor indicates how much actual earnings deviate from analyst forecasts.
| Report Date | Actual | Forecast | Surprise Factor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 09, 2026 | 3.49 | 3 | +16.33% |
| Dec 09, 2025 | 5.53 | 5.19 | +6.55% |
| Sep 08, 2025 | 5.77 | 5.02 | +14.94% |
| Jun 09, 2025 | 2.63 | 1.94 | +35.57% |
| Mar 11, 2025 | 2.33 | 1.99 | +17.09% |
| Dec 09, 2024 | 4.85 | 4.29 | +13.05% |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is CASY stock getting favorable reviews from Wall Street analysts?
Brokerage firms have given CASY stock an average recommendation of
Buy. 33 analysts have given their ratings
to CASY out of which
20 analysts have given strong buy call,
2 analysts have given buy call,
11 analysts rate it hold,
0 analysts advocate strong sell call, and
0 analysts has given sell rating. The average target price of
$642.15 gives the stock implied upside
of roughly -25.17% over the next year or so.
What have analysts suggested for CASY highest price target?
Analysts suggest CASY's stock price would rise to a high of $860.00.
What is the lowest price target analysts expect for CASY over the next year?
Within the next 12 months, analysts predict the CASY stock price could move to $450.00.
What is the average target price for CASY?
CASY stock has an average analyst estimate of $642.15.
At its current price, how far is CASY from its average target price?
CASY shares are currently trading -25.17% below this price target.
What were CASY’s actual earnings per share for the recent quarter?
Its quarterly earnings per share (EPS) came in at $3.49 versus consensus estimates of $3.00, and above the comparable year-ago quarter’s EPS of $2.33.
What are the current estimates for quarterly and annual earnings per share?
CASY's forecasts by analysts estimating quarterly EPS at $2.93 and $7.55 for the whole year.
What has CASY's growth been in the past five years and what is expected in the next five years?
The analysts have projected 13.55% EPS growth for CASY in the next five years, compared to growth rates of 15.58% in the past five years.