W. Andrew Carter

Q: What is W. Andrew Carter's success rate?

W. Andrew Carter currently has a success rate of 98.41196424021628.

Q: What is the average return of W. Andrew Carter's calls?

Their stock ratings have generated an average return of 20.4715684248528.

Stifel

W. Andrew Carter is an analyst from Stifel Ranked #775 out of 4774 analysts, they have issued 47 stock ratings with a success rate of 98.41% and an average return of 20.47%.

W. Andrew Carter has a well-established track record, with 47 ratings issued in the market sector. They have consistently delivered a success rate of 98.41% and an average return of 20.47%, underscoring their expertise and ability to identify winning opportunities for investors.

#775

Out of 4774

Total Ratings

+98.41%

Success Rate

+20.47%

Average Return

Recent Ratings Analysis

IBP

Buy

Sep 15, 2026

Target

$240.00

Current

$200.30

Performance

—

W. Andrew Carter rated IBP as Buy on Sep 15, 2026, setting a price target of 240. Shares have remained stable near 200.3, leaving the 240 target still in play.

UFPI

Hold

Aug 24, 2026

Target

$90.00

Current

$81.03

Performance

-9.19%

On Aug 24, 2026, UFPI was given a Hold rating by W. Andrew Carter, with a target price of 90. The rating provided protection from downside risk as the stock fell to 81.03.

SMG

Buy

Aug 03, 2026

Target

$76.00

Current

$55.91

Performance

-17.97%

SMG received a Buy rating from W. Andrew Carter on Aug 03, 2026, aiming for 76. The rating hasn’t played out as hoped, with the stock trading 17.97% below expectations.

SSD

Buy

Aug 03, 2026

Target

$218.00

Current

$171.59

Performance

-10.71%

On Aug 03, 2026, W. Andrew Carter published a Buy outlook on SSD, with a target of 218. Market action contradicted the Buy thesis, as shares slipped to 171.59.

SITE

Hold

Jul 30, 2026

Target

$100.00

Current

$89.34

Performance

-5.92%

W. Andrew Carter on Jul 30, 2026 assigned SITE a Hold rating, with a price target of 100. The call successfully avoided chasing as shares lost 5.92%.

POOL

Hold

Jul 24, 2026

Target

$189.00

Current

$171.76

Performance

-6.54%

On Jul 24, 2026, W. Andrew Carter reaffirmed POOL with a Hold rating, targeting 189. The Hold stance reflected market caution that was later justified.

WHR

Hold

Jul 23, 2026

Target

$37.00

Current

$34.00

Performance

-4.74%

WHR was rated Hold by W. Andrew Carter on Jul 23, 2026, with a price objective of 37. Flat performance suggests the Hold view was reasonable.

BLDR

Hold

Jul 23, 2026

Target

$70.00

Current

$60.24

Performance

-14.61%

On Jul 23, 2026, W. Andrew Carter initiated coverage on BLDR with a Hold rating and target of 70. The rating matched the stock’s inability to hold above 60.24.

TREX

Hold

Jul 14, 2026

Target

$47.00

Current

$43.66

Performance

-1.15%

W. Andrew Carter issued a Hold recommendation for TREX on Jul 14, 2026, price target set at 47. The rating was appropriate for a consolidating market trading near 43.66.

RH

Hold

Jun 12, 2026

Target

$130.00

Current

$134.17

Performance

-12.33%

On Jun 12, 2026, RH was evaluated by W. Andrew Carter, who gave a Hold rating and target of 130. The Hold call avoided chasing into subsequent weakness of 12.33%.

LOW

Hold

May 18, 2026

Target

$220.00

Current

$198.26

Performance

-9.06%

W. Andrew Carter rated LOW as Hold on May 18, 2026, setting a price target of 220. The cautious Hold call aligned with subsequent weakness, as shares slipped 9.06%.

HD

Hold

May 18, 2026

Target

$320.00

Current

$310.87

Performance

3.69%

On May 18, 2026, HD was given a Hold rating by W. Andrew Carter, with a target price of 320. Market indecision, reflected in sideways trading near 310.87, supported the cautious call.

ARHS

Buy

May 11, 2026

Target

$11.00

Current

$8.12

Performance

32.68%

ARHS received a Buy rating from W. Andrew Carter on May 11, 2026, aiming for 11. Momentum has favored the Buy call, with shares climbing from 8.12 to 8.12, rewarding those who trusted the recommendation.

SWIM

Buy

Mar 04, 2026

Target

$9.50

Current

$6.40

Performance

—

On Mar 04, 2026, W. Andrew Carter published a Buy outlook on SWIM, with a target of 9.5. So far, the stock has neither confirmed nor rejected the Buy case, holding within range of 6.4.

HAYW

Buy

Feb 26, 2026

Target

$19.50

Current

$12.87

Performance

-18.44%

W. Andrew Carter on Feb 26, 2026 assigned HAYW a Buy rating, with a price target of 19.5. The call has struggled to gain traction, with shares losing 18.44%.

FND

Buy

Dec 16, 2025

Target

$92.00

Current

$48.13

Performance

-21.66%

On Dec 16, 2025, W. Andrew Carter reaffirmed FND with a Buy rating, targeting 92. Shares slid 21.66% despite the recommendation, highlighting downside risks.

HLMN

Buy

Aug 29, 2025

Target

$12.00

Current

$7.21

Performance

-27.02%

HLMN was rated Buy by W. Andrew Carter on Aug 29, 2025, with a price objective of 12. This case shows how bullish projections can fail, with the stock now below 7.21.

LESL

Sell

Feb 07, 2025

Target

$1.55

Current

$0.49

Performance

-98.50%

On Feb 07, 2025, W. Andrew Carter initiated coverage on LESL with a Sell rating and target of 1.55. Shares gained despite the bearish call, moving higher from 0.4927.

BECN

Hold

Feb 07, 2025

Target

$122.55

Current

$124.17

Performance

3.73%

W. Andrew Carter issued a Hold recommendation for BECN on Feb 07, 2025, price target set at 122.55. The rating was appropriate for a consolidating market trading near 124.17.

HYFM

Hold

Jul 29, 2024

Target

$0.75

Current

$0.95

Performance

-85.09%

On Jul 29, 2024, HYFM was evaluated by W. Andrew Carter, who gave a Hold rating and target of 0.75. The Hold call avoided chasing into subsequent weakness of 85.09%.

GRWG

Hold

Jul 29, 2024

Target

$2.50

Current

$1.55

Performance

-32.90%

W. Andrew Carter rated GRWG as Hold on Jul 29, 2024, setting a price target of 2.5. The cautious Hold call aligned with subsequent weakness, as shares slipped 32.90%.

Frequency Asked Questions

Who is W. Andrew Carter?

W. Andrew Carter is an analyst from Stifel.

What is W. Andrew Carter's success rate?

W. Andrew Carter currently has a success rate of +98.41%.

How many ratings has W. Andrew Carter issued?

W. Andrew Carter has issued 47 stock ratings so far.

What is the average return of W. Andrew Carter's calls?

Their stock ratings have generated an average return of +20.47%.

What is W. Andrew Carter's ranking?

W. Andrew Carter is ranked #775 out of 4774 analysts.

What types of ratings does W. Andrew Carter give?

Their ratings include Buy, Hold, and Sell recommendations, depending on the stock’s outlook.

How can I follow W. Andrew Carter?

You can follow W. Andrew Carter by clicking the "Follow Analyst" button on this page to receive updates on their stock calls.

What is the most recent rating by W. Andrew Carter?

Their latest rating was a Buy on IBP issued on 2026-09-15.