Matthew J. Carletti

Q: What is Matthew J. Carletti's success rate?

Matthew J. Carletti currently has a success rate of 85.37558330916603.

Q: What is the average return of Matthew J. Carletti's calls?

Their stock ratings have generated an average return of 5.230548435773431.

Citizens

Matthew J. Carletti is an analyst from Citizens Ranked #2094 out of 4658 analysts, they have issued 24 stock ratings with a success rate of 85.38% and an average return of 5.23%.

Matthew J. Carletti has a well-established track record, with 24 ratings issued in the market sector. They have consistently delivered a success rate of 85.38% and an average return of 5.23%, underscoring their expertise and ability to identify winning opportunities for investors.

#2094

Out of 4658

Total Ratings

+85.38%

Success Rate

+5.23%

Average Return

Recent Ratings Analysis

BRO

Buy

May 21, 2026

Target

$70.00

Current

$57.43

Performance

—

Matthew J. Carletti rated BRO as Market Outperform on May 21, 2026, setting a price target of 70. Shares have remained stable near 57.43, leaving the 70 target still in play.

AII

Buy

May 13, 2026

Target

$25.00

Current

$16.60

Performance

-1.60%

On May 13, 2026, AII was given a Market Outperform rating by Matthew J. Carletti, with a target price of 25. The stock traded sideways with a -1.60% move, keeping the bullish thesis unresolved.

LIFE

Buy

May 07, 2026

Target

$27.00

Current

$20.02

Performance

-34.55%

LIFE received a Market Outperform rating from Matthew J. Carletti on May 07, 2026, aiming for 27. The rating hasn’t played out as hoped, with the stock trading 34.55% below expectations.

HG

Buy

May 01, 2026

Target

$38.00

Current

$32.39

Performance

—

On May 01, 2026, Matthew J. Carletti published a Market Outperform outlook on HG, with a target of 38. So far, the stock has neither confirmed nor rejected the Buy case, holding within range of 32.39.

LMND

Buy

Apr 30, 2026

Target

$80.00

Current

$57.36

Performance

1.27%

Matthew J. Carletti on Apr 30, 2026 assigned LMND a Market Outperform rating, with a price target of 80. The recommendation remains pending validation as shares consolidate around 57.36.

THG

Buy

Apr 30, 2026

Target

$205.00

Current

$194.56

Performance

3.66%

On Apr 30, 2026, Matthew J. Carletti reaffirmed THG with a Market Outperform rating, targeting 205. Market indecision has kept the 205 target in a holding pattern.

CB

Buy

Apr 22, 2026

Target

$365.00

Current

$328.38

Performance

0.91%

CB was rated Market Outperform by Matthew J. Carletti on Apr 22, 2026, with a price objective of 365. The stock is in a wait-and-see zone, leaving the Buy case open-ended.

GSHD

Buy

Feb 18, 2026

Target

$140.00

Current

$41.37

Performance

-12.70%

On Feb 18, 2026, Matthew J. Carletti initiated coverage on GSHD with a Market Outperform rating and target of 140. The Buy call has yet to be validated as shares remain 98.63 away from the target.

KMPR

Hold

Feb 05, 2026

Target

—

Current

$29.50

Performance

-11.84%

Matthew J. Carletti issued a Market Perform recommendation for KMPR on Feb 05, 2026, price target set at null. Market action validated the conservative Hold outlook with shares at 29.5.

STC

Buy

Feb 02, 2026

Target

$80.00

Current

$68.12

Performance

-0.31%

On Feb 02, 2026, STC was evaluated by Matthew J. Carletti, who gave a Market Outperform rating and target of 80. So far, the Buy call awaits clearer momentum, with shares flat at 68.12.

RLI

Hold

Jan 23, 2026

Target

—

Current

$52.64

Performance

-7.60%

Matthew J. Carletti rated RLI as Market Perform on Jan 23, 2026, setting a price target of null. The cautious Hold call aligned with subsequent weakness, as shares slipped 7.60%.

HCI

Buy

Nov 10, 2025

Target

$255.00

Current

$158.20

Performance

-16.12%

On Nov 10, 2025, HCI was given a Market Outperform rating by Matthew J. Carletti, with a target price of 255. Despite the Buy call, shares fell from 158.2 to 158.2, challenging the optimistic stance.

SKWD

Buy

Oct 30, 2025

Target

$75.00

Current

$47.39

Performance

3.83%

SKWD received a Market Outperform rating from Matthew J. Carletti on Oct 30, 2025, aiming for 75. Price action was muted, as shares hovered around 47.39 despite the bullish outlook.

AMSF

Buy

Oct 14, 2025

Target

$60.00

Current

$31.37

Performance

-25.58%

On Oct 14, 2025, Matthew J. Carletti published a Market Outperform outlook on AMSF, with a target of 60. Market action contradicted the Buy thesis, as shares slipped to 31.37.

HIPO

Buy

Oct 14, 2025

Target

$45.00

Current

$25.99

Performance

-26.71%

Matthew J. Carletti on Oct 14, 2025 assigned HIPO a Market Outperform rating, with a price target of 45. The call has struggled to gain traction, with shares losing 26.71%.

BOW

Buy

Oct 14, 2025

Target

$40.00

Current

$28.56

Performance

5.12%

On Oct 14, 2025, Matthew J. Carletti reaffirmed BOW with a Market Outperform rating, targeting 40. The recommendation was supported by strong follow-through as the stock rose from 28.56 to 28.56.

ARX

Hold

Aug 18, 2025

Target

—

Current

$16.69

Performance

-41.54%

ARX was rated Market Perform by Matthew J. Carletti on Aug 18, 2025, with a price objective of null. Investors who stayed cautious avoided some of the 41.54% decline.

Frequency Asked Questions

Who is Matthew J. Carletti?

Matthew J. Carletti is an analyst from Citizens.

What is Matthew J. Carletti's success rate?

Matthew J. Carletti currently has a success rate of +85.38%.

How many ratings has Matthew J. Carletti issued?

Matthew J. Carletti has issued 24 stock ratings so far.

What is the average return of Matthew J. Carletti's calls?

Their stock ratings have generated an average return of +5.23%.

What is Matthew J. Carletti's ranking?

Matthew J. Carletti is ranked #2094 out of 4658 analysts.

What types of ratings does Matthew J. Carletti give?

Their ratings include Buy, Hold, and Sell recommendations, depending on the stock’s outlook.

How can I follow Matthew J. Carletti?

You can follow Matthew J. Carletti by clicking the "Follow Analyst" button on this page to receive updates on their stock calls.

What is the most recent rating by Matthew J. Carletti?

Their latest rating was a Buy on BRO issued on 2026-05-21.